Reader Tribe

Writer Tribe

  • Important Dates
  • Nomination Rules
  • Past Awards
  • January 2024 | Nominations
  • March 2024 | Finals
  • Last updated: 4/02/24 – 07:00 pm CST


If you find a spelling mistake feel free to contact us. If your nomination is not listed below and you submitted by the above time, it is most likely vetoed. See FAQ for more information.

  1. Do not nominate your own book, or a book you have not read.
  2. All nominations must be:
    – Indie (self) published during the previous year.
    – A Novella or Novel. (60+ Amazon listed page count.)
    – Fantasy
    – No main-plot romance. (If the plot doesn’t work without the romance, then it is main-plot romance.)
    – Published in English.
    – Submitted in the following format: Title by Author. Any other format will be disqualified.
    – 5 Reviews on Amazon, with a rating of at least 4.0
  3. The top 10 books will advance to the Finals.
    1. Each author will only be allowed ONE book to advance to the next round.
    2. To advance a book MUST have a minimum of 5 nominations.
  4. A person can only nominate:
    – a book once.
    – 3 books total.
    – Note: emails ending in .gov, .edu, .org are invalid. 
    – 18 years or older to participate.
  5. By nominating you are subscribing to the Caffeinated Fantasy Newsletter.
  6. Nominations will be validated after they have closed, and books that do not meet the above qualifications will be removed.
  7. During the nomination round, making it to the current standings chart doesn’t verify that the book has met all qualifications.

Check out our FAQ.

Congratulations to the 2023 Book of the Year!

Wormwood Abbey
by Christina Baehr

Page Count: 208

Published: 10-6-23

Kindle Unlimited: No

Goodreads: 4.4 Stars

Amazon: 4.6 Stars

Blurb:

As a Victorian clergyman’s daughter, Edith Worms has seen everything — until a mythical salamander tumbles out of the fireplace into her lap.

When a letter arrives from estranged relatives, Edith is swept away to a crumbling gothic Abbey in the wilds of Yorkshire. Wormwood Abbey isn’t just full of curious beasts and ancient family secrets: there’s also a tall, dark, and entirely too handsome neighbour who is strangely reluctant for her to leave.

An unexpected bond with her prickly cousin Gwendolyn gives Edith a reason to stay in this strange world — especially when it turns out that Edith herself may have a role in guarding her family’s legacy.

But not all of the mysteries of Ormdale are small enough to fit in her lap…and some of them have teeth.

WORMWOOD ABBEY, Book 1 of The Secrets of Ormdale, is a cosy gothic novel of mystery, dragons, and the perils of friendship, perfect for fans of Emily Wilde’s Encyclopaedia of Faeries and Maria Grace.

Start exploring the hidden valley of Ormdale in 1899 with WORMWOOD ABBEY, the first in a new 5 book series.

To Bind Fire
by D. E. Carlson

Page Count: 453

Published: 10-17-23

Kindle Unlimited: Yes

Goodreads: 4.4 Stars

Amazon: 4.5 Stars

Check Out This
Book’s Spotlight Post

Drinks and Sinkholes
S. Usher Evans

Page Count: 310

Published: 9-5-23

Kindle Unlimited: No

Goodreads: 3.9 Stars

Amazon: 4.3 Stars

Check Out This
Book’s Spotlight Post

Full House
by R. L. King

Page Count: 539

Published: 11-28-23

Kindle Unlimited: Yes

Goodreads: 4.8 Stars

Amazon: 4.8 Stars

Check Out This
Book’s Spotlight Post

Grave Crusade
John P. Logsdon

Page Count: 396

Published: 2-27-23

Kindle Unlimited: Yes

Goodreads: 4.6 Stars

Amazon: 4.6 Stars

Check Out This
Book’s Spotlight Post

Break the Beast
Allison Tebo

Page Count: 270

Published: 9-15-23

Kindle Unlimited: Yes

Goodreads: 4.8 Stars

Amazon: 4.7 Stars

Check Out This
Book’s Spotlight Post

The Orb and the Airship
Jenelle Leanne Schmidt

Page Count: 378

Published: 6-16-23

Kindle Unlimited: Yes

Goodreads: 4.5 Stars

Amazon: 4.6 Stars

Check Out This
Book’s Spotlight Post

Marked by Magic
by Lindsay Buroker

Page Count: 342

Published: 11-9-23

Kindle Unlimited: Yes

Goodreads: 4.4 Stars

Amazon: 4.6 Stars

Check Out This
Book’s Spotlight Post

The Necessity of Rain
Sarah Chorn

Page Count: 336

Published: 6-27-23

Kindle Unlimited: Yes

Goodreads: 4.6 Stars

Amazon: 4.6 Stars

Check Out This
Book’s Spotlight Post

Dark & Stormy
by Suzannah Rowntree

Page Count: 306

Published: 9-21-23

Kindle Unlimited: No

Goodreads: 4.4 Stars

Amazon: 4.5 Stars

Check Out This
Book’s Spotlight Post

Want to help plan next years awards?
Join us on Patreon!

Pinterest
Pinterest
fb-share-icon
Instagram
YouTube
YouTube